Up and Running Blog

Generic Advice About Asking for Generic Advice

by Tim Berry on January 6, 2009

Seems like I’m getting a new flow of e-mail lately from well-meaning people asking for “tips on new business” or “tips on starting a business,” as if there were some storehouse of generic tip treasures that are waiting to be distributed.

Here are two examples:

I ran across you on [the web] and wanted to send you an e-mail and see if you would offer any advice in, well, any part of this new direction I am taking. I read your “About Me” section on your site and you have seen it all! This is something completely new to me and I am looking to do better than most right out of the gates. Anything you can offer would be appreciated!

I have been working in my field for more than a decade now. I believe I am quite adept at meeting challenges, too, but I get numb when it comes to starting up a new venture or business of my own. Basically, lots of ideas just scatter away. I always get this feeling that a paper plan is good enough only if it’s simple, actionable and time bound. What do you think? I need some sound advice and tips from a man like you who has seen it all.

How do I answer requests like those? As soon as I start to even think about it, the obvious platitudes well up in my brain like a flood of useless, boring, obvious advice: Give value. Be true to yourself. Do something you like doing, something that people will pay for. Buy low, sell high. Bootstrapping is better if you can get away with it, but can be bad if you end up stifling a business that might have prospered with more capital. Don’t spend more than you take in.

Business, and particularly startup business, isn’t generic. Every case is different. I like answering questions–you can see a bunch of my answers at Entrepreneur.com and at bplans.com–but I don’t have a stock answer for a request for general generic wisdom.

About Tim Berry

Tim Berry

Tim Berry is the founder of Palo Alto Software, a co-founder of Borland International, and a recognized expert in business planning. Tim is the originator of plan-as-you-go business planning. He has an MBA from Stanford and degrees with honors from the University of Oregon and the University of Notre Dame. Today, Tim dedicates most of his time to blogging, teaching, and evangelizing for business planning. His full biography is available on his blog.

More from Tim Berry

Tags:


{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

James H Shewmaker January 6, 2009 at 8:50 am

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. – George Santayana

The DIY path for the novice entrepreneur is usually more expensive due to mistakes than finding trustworthy freelance experts.

James Shewmaker
Qwerty

Reply

Ken Pirok January 6, 2009 at 3:23 pm

The problem isn’t your answers; it’s their questions.

If someone asks a specific question, then an experienced entrepreneur or consultant can probably answer it. If one asks a generic question, then the answer will just be more of the same.

When I meet with prospective clients, I actually ask them the questions. I interview them-pretty extensively. Then, I get to a point where I explain how I can help them, and, at that point, I can intelligently answer their questions.

Reply

iffat gharbi January 7, 2009 at 4:46 am

Hi I live in dubai, uae. I want to start a family business but what is my best option for the current economic situation?

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: